(1) 10 reasons demos tapes are rejected
(2) Advice from a record label.
countrywesternbands.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Getting a deal" has long been
the goal of many would-be artists and bands.
For mostly naive reasons, most new talent
feel
that by securing a recording contract with
a significant major or independent label,
success will be guaranteed. (But that’s
another story) To get this ‘belief system’
up and running, many musicians figure all
they have to do is send off their music to
a label, and a recording contract will come
their way shortly.
The following list of ‘10 Reasons Why Demo
Tapes Are Rejected’ was gathered together
from years of listening to
comments made by Record Label A&R reps
at music industry conferences and workshops,
as well as from personal
interviews with reps, and from many interviews
given to the press. In addition, I can verify
that these observations are
true from having personally listened to thousands
of demo tapes over the years.
The purpose of providing you with this information
is to at least improve the odds that your
music get listened to when
you submit your demo tapes. This article
will look at the most common mistakes musicians
make when either shopping
for a record deals, or trying to get the
attention of A&R Reps.
10 Reasons Demo Tapes are Rejected.
1. No Contact Information on Jcard and/or Tape
Label.
Yes, it’s true...many artists forget to include
their name, address, and/or phone number
on their tapes. As hard as it is to
believe, I have encountered this error countless
times over the years. I have received dozens
of tapes without any contact information
on them. A&R Reps are constantly having
to remind people of this basic habit. I have
always felt that this mistake had more to
do
with a "premature ego"than simple
forgetfulness. ("My music is so great,
it speaks for itself...discover me!".)
But to be fair, the excitement
of actually believing there is a realistic
chance that a recording contract may result
from sending the music, may have something
to do with
this momentary lapse of professionalism.
To make matters quite clear, whenever you
send a tape, be sure to TYPE your name, address,
and phone number on the JCard
and the tape label. These days it wouldn’t
hurt to also type in your email address,
and even a website URL if you have one. The
reason for the TYPED comment, is that many
times the handwriting of many would-be stars
is unreadable. The way I look at it,
the odds of making a living making music
are hard enough without adding unneeded problems
to the pile of obstacles that come along.
2. Lack of Originality.
I think one of the hardest realities for
a new or developing artist to accept, is
that their music is not "original".
A certain pride comes
from writing, recording, and performing your
own music. Many musicians are also loners.
They are, as a potential artist should be,
all wrapped up in their music, and what sounds
good to them is one thing, and what friends
and family say is irrelevant for the most
part because most closely related family
and friends want to encourage, not discourage.
Even a live audience cannot always be trusted
to give honest feedback. Many developing
acts perform in front of audiences who are
just at the show to have a good time, and
if your
music is played error free, and is competently
performed, you will most likely get a good
response.
A&R Reps are another breed. They have
a whole different spin on music. Anyone seriously
considering "getting signed" should
spend
some time reflecting on the following observation.
A&R Reps get paid to discover unique
talent. Talent that they and their superiors
at
the record label feel has a distinct sound
all it’s own. It was best expressed by my
former label partner Howie Klein this way.
He said
at a NAMA Music Conference in the early 90’s,
when he was then General Manager of Sire
Records (He is now the President of
Reprise Records), that many of the demo tapes
he heard were simply rehashes of what the
Warner family of labels already had signed!
This observation really articulates an important
fact. Many developing artists think that
if a certain sound is currently popular,
than they
can take advantage of the "bandwagon"
effect and easily get signed. I will admit
to you, and popular music’s history will
bare this out, that
many artists do indeed get signed because
of the industry’s ability to spot trends
and take advantage of them. But there is
also a trap in this
thinking. Truly original music is very difficult
to find. Once in blue moon an artist comes
along who’s music is so distinctive and original
that
they become trendsetters, and perhaps a whole
new "school" or genre of music
can be traced to them. If record labels waited
around for
only these kinds of artists, the music industry
would simple be a cottage industry, and not
the $20 billion dollar worldwide industry
it is today.
A&R Reps really don’t ask for much. In
fact the one thing they all seem to say is
something to the affect that " I just
want to hear ONE THING
that is different or unique in a band or
artist’s music." Well, that gives one
reason to hope, doesn’t it? So, ask yourself,
what is the one thing
about my music that is truly unique and stands
out from everything else? The music business
is concerned with one thing, and one thing
only.
Will the music of the artist signed to the
label sell? If you have any kind of truly
unique music that has a ‘niche’ in the marketplace,
there is
some chance then that you can fight the good
fight, and get the attention of the industry.
But, as we shall see, in the 1990’s, just
having unique
and distinctive music isn’t even enough.
The labels are looking more and more to artists
who have taken significant steps to prove
to them
that they have some marketable music.
3. The Music Is good, But The Artist Doesn’t
Play Live And/Or Has No Self Produced CD’s.
Want to hear the sound of an instant dialtone?
Submit a great tape of unique and distinctive
music to an A&R rep, and when they surprise
you with a phone call requesting to see you
play live...say you don’t have a live act.
That will enable you to use that automatic
dialtone to
phone around to your musician friends, and
start putting together a live band, assuming
of course that you haven’t had a heart attack
from
the shock of being hung up on. Playing live
is simply the heart of the issue. It is from
playing live that you will be able to assemble
a mailing
list of fans to build you careers from.
Any doubts? Just ask Ani DeFranco, Fugasi,
Loreena McKinnett, and dozens of other artists.
We live in an era when the "do it yourself"
ethic of the alternative music scene of the
mid 70’s has become the best way to prepare
for
record label attention. As recording technology
has improved, the ease of making your own
record (CD or Tape) has also grown. Interview
after interview with contemporary A&R
reps reflect the sentiment that when a solo
artist or band has taken the trouble to get
their
professional act together and recorded a
CD, and then found innovative ways to play
live in their city or town selling their
product
at every show, the more likely that the "buzz’
created by these activities will expand to
include some possible local airplay at
noncommercial radio, and garner the attention
of the local and regional music press.
In other words, anyone seriously hoping to
get signed to a label, should be an entrepreneur
of sorts. Not only are the labels
more apt to become aware of you, but by engaging
in these activities you will actually begin
to learn the business of the business,
which comes in handy when you do get signed.
I can assure you that any astute label owner
will appreciate a passionate, and
energetic musician who has taken control
of their own destiny, and delivered to the
label a fanbase of customers that they can
then
build from. Now, you’re talkin’ the label’s
language!
4. Poorly Recorded Material.
Even though, as I already said, recording
technology has made it easier for musicians
to release a more professional sounding
demo, many tapes received by A&R reps
do not demonstrate an understanding of the
quality inherent in current popular music
recordings. I should also say that the comments
I make here need to be considered in a certain
light. Many reps do not care that
much about "studio quality" recordings.
For these reps hearing some "magic"
in the grooves (so to speak) is what matters.
Nevertheless,
many rock and rap acts continue to submit
tapes recorded live on a personal hand-held
cassette deck, or some other inferior deck.
With the exception of acoustic acts, where
a quality recording can result from a simple
recording of the artist with a guitar or
piano,
most other music should try to get at least
a 4 track recording done. Look at it this
way. Everything starts with the music. It
seems to
me that as a matter of pride the best quality
recording should always be the goal. Why
risk rejection over a few hundred dollars
investment?
5. Tape Is Not Rewound And Cued-up.
It is simply a matter of courtesy and professionalism
to take the time to rewind and cue-up your
tape. Some things in life you would
presume people would just take for granted,
but the longer you live the more you realize
that nothing can be taken for granted. This
issue; which obviously has nothing to do
with the quality of your music, or your talent
as a singer, songwriter, or musician can
however
play a part in having your tape rejected.
A&R reps like every other professional,
are very busy people. As many as 50 to 100
demo
tapes a week can come to the attention of
a rep. When they make time to listen to your
tape, they expect the music to be ready to
listen
to. Think about it. Have you ever put a music
tape in your car tape deck, pressed play
and either the tape was past the place you
wanted
to hear, or you weren’t sure where it was
on the tape? Well, that is as close as you’ll
get to feeling the frustration that A&R
Reps feel
when they pop your tape into their decks,
and all they hear is tape hiss.
Many reps have expressed their frustration
over this issue, and almost all of them will
tell you that you have blown your chance
to
impress them with your music. With so many
tapes to listen to, they will just move on
to the next tape in their pile. So, don’t
forget
to remember to "frontload" your
tape, and cue it up to the first song on
your tape. There is nothing sweeter to the
ear of a rep than
to hear a song start within a second or two
of having pressed the play button.
6. Sending Videotapes In Place Of Audio Cassettes
or CDs
The home video camera has revolutionized
the childhood memories business, as well
as allowed people to preserve many family
and friends events. As for music, the home
video camera comes in very handy when an
act wants to see what they look like on
stage. In fact. using a camera for that purpose
is an excellent device for musicians to see
what they look like on stage, from the
audience point of view. Remember, cameras
never lie.
However, when it comes to submitting music
to an A&R rep, leave your videos at home.
Any submissions should be either on tape,
or on CD. If you want to mention that you
have a quality video of a live show, and
allow
them to decide if they want to watch it,
that is fine, but many artists and bands
have sent videos instead of audio cassettes.
That should
never happen.
7. Sending Unsolicited Tapes.
An unsolicited tape is a tape sent to a record
label, without the label having requested
it.
Generally speaking, most major labels, and
some indies as well, refuse to accept such
tapes. Over the years the labels encountered
too
many lawsuits from people who had sent in
tapes that the labels had rejected, and then
claimed in a lawsuit that their songs had
been
stolen by the labels and given to successful
artists to sing. To this day however, hundreds
of tapes arrive at the labels, and in most
cases they are promptly returned with a standard
cover letter explaining their unsolicited
tape policy.
But, as you can probably guess by now, I
come from a place that is concerned with
controlling all aspects of one’s career.
And to just
"shotgun" out a bunch of tapes
to some addresses from a label directory
demonstrates an irresponsibility on the artist’s
behalf.
No tape or CD should be sent to anyone in
the music business without either a request,
or a recommendation from someone to do so.
If you met an A&R Rep at a club, or at
a music conference and they gave you their
card, then it is important to send them your
music.
If a personal connection opens a door for
you at a label and alerts the rep to your
coming tape that is also fine. The idea is
to only send
your music when some kind of a connection
has been made. Be sure however that when
you do send your tape, that along with it
in your
demo kit is a cover letter that reminds the
rep of your connection, or their request.
They get so many tapes, and meet so many
artists and
bands, that you need to take the time to
remind them of who you are, and why you are
sending your music to them.
8. Sending The Wrong Music To The Wrong Label.
This comes about mainly when "shotgunning"
takes place, but sometimes even the most
well intentioned artist, or friend of an
artist, will
get their music to a label that has no interest
in that particular style of music. I remember
getting tapes from friends in the business,
who I
thought a great deal of, only to find their
name mentioned in the cover letter I was
reading, while wondering why they had suggested
I
listen to the tape. 415 Records was an alternative
rock label in San Francisco, and I still
have countless demo tapes of music not related
to that genre, stashed in a box in my basement.
Jazz groups, Blues bands, and even Country
and Western bands tapes would come my way.
I have conversations with many label reps
over the years and asked them if this ever
happened to them. I always got a good few
minutes of
precious anecdotes from the reps laughing
about the problem
As artists, every tape you send out has your
hopes and dreams attached to it. Take a little
time to research the labels you intend to
court.
Do they really release music similar to yours
in style? Would they realistically ever even
think about putting that rap record out at
that
alternative label? In addition, every tape
you wrongly send out, costs you money.
The tape, the envelope, the postage...it
all adds up after awhile. Carefully research
not only the genre of music of the label
you are interested in,
but while you’re at it, take some time to
check on their reputation too. Do you really
want to be on that label?
9. Musicians Can’t Play Their Instruments
Competently.
Many young musicians tend to rush things
when it comes to being proficient on their
instruments. It takes more than a few weeks,
or a
few months to even ‘get acquainted’ with
a guitar, bass, drum kit, or keyboard. Even
genre like ‘punk’ or ‘grunge’ require a certain
level
of competency, and a good A&R rep can
spot a lack of instrument competency within
seconds. As for more sophisticated pop music,
or blues and jazz, it becomes increasingly
more important for young musicians to be
very proficient on their chosen instrument,
before even
thinking about shopping a tape of their music.
The best barometer for judging instrument
competency for any pop, jazz, blues, or instrumental
music is to ask yourself this question. Does
my playing equal the skills demonstrated
by the music I hear on the radio? If not,
what makes you
think that a record label would want to sign
an artist that can’t live up to that standard?
10. The Music Sucks.
One of my favorite quotes from 1996 was this
one. "Nobody wants to hear one piece
of crap anymore than they want to hear a
whole lot
of crap". Well, we had to mention this
didn’t we? I could have addressed this issue
under the ‘originality’ section, but "sucking"
is a far cry
from not being original. Granted, some ‘original’
musical concepts can suck too, but the issue
I am talking about has more to do with not
being proficient enough as a songwriter.
‘Sucking" has everything to do with
being rejected. The industry reps have estimated
that over 90%
of the music they receive ‘sucks’. I agree
with this opinion. Think about it, with the
ease of recording, and the low cost of recording
these days,
everybody can and seemingly does want to
be a star.
Just because you have a few songs, and have
even rehearsed them a few times, doesn’t
mean you are ready for prime time. It takes
a
special talent to be able to write a good
song, So take the time to be at least ‘good’.
Remember too that the word ‘good’ is very
overused these days. ‘Good’ isn’t really
enough! What gets things going for any artist,
is that they write GREAT SONGS!! Great
songs are your musical heritage. All the
songs that meant anything to you over the
years were GREAT SONGS. Are your songs up
to
that standard? Think about it.
Some Final Thoughts.
I would like to suggest a few other things
related to getting signed that might come
in handy before committing to shopping for
a record
deal. In the event that something should
happen with your tape that is positive; meaning,
you receive ‘interest’ from some label, the
following
observation might be useful for you to consider.
Do you have an Entertainment Law Attorney?
Any reputable A&R rep worth anything
will tell you that it is a very rare occasion
when an artist or band is signed directly
because of a
demo tape being sent to them. It may lead
to showing some interest in the act, and
a desire for more music, or a request to
send them a
schedule of your upcoming live shows. But
rarely is an artist signed because of the
demo tape alone. In any case, when some serious
interest
is shown by the label, they will want to
know who represents you. If your answer is
that you have no legal counsel, it goes against
you in their
eyes. To them it can mean that you either
are a very naive act, and one prone to easy
manipulation, or simply that you are not
prepared for the
possibility of being signed. One of the first
people a developing act should have on their
team is an entertainment law attorney. Notice,
I didn’t say just any old attorney. Entertainment
law is a very complex specialty, and all
acts serious about making it in the music
business,
should make it a priority to engage the services
of a well respected, and well connected entertainment
law attorney. Look at it this way...you
are a rep who has taken strong interest in
a hot act, and you want to step up and get
something going with the act. Then you ask
the question
"Who is your 1attorney?"....remember
that dialtone sound?
There are always exceptions to rules, and
the topic I have just discussed is one of
those topics where exception have, and will
continue to be
made. My point in all these issues is that
there are only so many opportunities to make
it in this business. By knowing the most
common
mistakes, we can hopefully prevent any of
these points from being the reason your music
was rejected.
And Another Thing ...
The one point I always return to is this.
Is there really something...ONE THING even
about your music, your singing, your playing,
your
performance that is truly unique. Find what
that is and exaggerate it! Make it noticeable.
Be proud of it. A&R reps are employees
of record
labels. They are paid to find the best talent
that is out there. And, in case you didn’t
know, their careers go only as far as the
talent they
discover. Their careers can prosper or fail
with yours. Give them only the best...your
best.
One other thing..."Follow Through!"
It’s really this simple. If you do not intend
to contact the person you sent your music
to, then don’t
even bother to send your music in the first
place. This business is a ‘personal relationship’
business, and the last word is this. Establish
the
reputation of being a professional musician
in everything you do. When you send out your
music, begin the ‘follow-up’ process about
5-7
working days after the mailing. Be patient
and persistent and willing to fight the good
fight.
Reflecting on everything I have said in this
article, I am struck by the fact that all
the issues I have raised can really be summarized
into one
simple fact, the ignorance of which will
hurt your chances of success more than anything
else. There are more letters in the word
‘business’
than there are in the word ‘music’.
When you started out learning to play your
instrument you believed the professionals
who told you to buy the best instrument you
could afford.
You believed them. When you invested in equipment,
your intention was to get the best that your
budget allowed: again professionals in the
business told you about the importance of
good reliable equipment, and once again,
you believed them. Then, when you were ready
to present
your original music to the world, you asked
every question you could about what it takes
to compete in the world of popular music....oh
wait...
.did you forget to do that? Ask yourself
this question. Why is it that when it came
to conducting your career professionally,
that you didn’t ask
questions about the business of music, and
take the advise of music business professionals
who deal with musicians and their music every
day?
All of the questions I have presented in
this article have answers that any musician
who is serious about making money from their
music should
study and know about.
The days of ‘being discovered’ without proper
preparation are over. The successful musician
of the new millennium, is one who takes charge
of every aspect of their career, and by their
efforts attracts attention from the powers
that be, who are always on the lookout for
upcoming,
great talent, and may be able to help you
if you have taken the trouble to help yourself
with the business of music.
The fantasy of becoming a star is easy, but
the road to stardom involves hard work, and
a determination to succeed that knows no
bounds.
It has been said that ‘luck’ is when preparation
meets opportunity. How prepared are you?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How does a performer get a record deal?
It is mainly talent and a lot of luck. If
you are a band, put together a few songs,
rehearse them well, and then start
playing at local concert venues. You can
book yourself into these venues by sending
them tapes of your band playing,
and a press package with a photo and your
band's history.
With some luck, along the way you will get
to know some music industry people. If they
really like your music, they will
connect you with the right A&R people
(these are people who actively goes out and
looks for talent to sign to a record label).
It is also very important to get a good manager.
A good manager will have all of those contacts
in the music industry,
and know A&R people. A lot of management
companies also hold open auditions for bands
and new artists.
Check in your local newspapers or trade magazines
such as Variety and Backstage for auditions.
What does a record company do for an artist?
A record company basically acts as a bank,
a salesman, a cheerleader, and a post office
for the artist. Once signed
to a label, a record company will loan the
artist the money to record an album, develop
you as an artist (ie: dance
classes, voice classes), and support your
promotional and concert tour. In the meantime,
the label is also working
to get your album in record stores, and coming
up with ideas on how to market you and your
music.
After everyone has figured out what songs
will be on the album, the artwork, your image,
your hit single, etc.
the record label then hooks up with a distribution
company to get your CDs in all of those stores.
One thing you must remember: All of the costs
that goes into recording the album, developing
you as an artist,
artwork, tour support must be given back
to the record label! This is what the industry
call Recoupable Costs.
In other words, the record label will give
you all this money to do all these things
in advance, but once your album
starts selling, they are going to recoup
the amount of money they loaned you from
the album sales until they are
fully paid back. Essentially, everyone get
paid with the money that is made from album
sales: the record company,
the publishing company (people who wrote
the songs), your managers, your agents, etc.
and you will all get a
percentage of the record sale.
What advice would you give a newly signed
band or singer?
Take some business classes! A lot of artists
who are really talented have no business
sense at all, and they are
usually the ones that gets screwed over by
their managers, accountants, and yes, the
record labels. It is very
important that you know exactly where all
your money is going to, what percentage of
the album's profits will go
to you as a performer and as a publisher,
how many albums you are contracted to make
with a record label, etc.
Also, keep yourself humble. Nobody likes
an artist that is full of themselves and
thinks that they are the best thing
that's ever happened to music. That kind
of attitude has made an artist less popular
in more cases than I can count.
How does someone know what a record label
is looking for?
This is a tough question. A record label
is always looking to set the trend in music.
They don't usually look for
something that already exists. With that
said, however, labels do go through periods
of time when they sign an act
that is very similar to what is already out
there and making a lot of money (i.e.: Backstreet
Boys were doing so well
that there was enough room in the market
for another band like them - 'N Sync").
But usually these trends do not last,
and pretty soon, people get tired of the
same type of music and they want something
new.
Basically, if you believe in the type of
music you are making, then don't change yourself.
Don't change your style or
your music to suit what you think the rest
of the world will like - because they haven't
heard your music yet, and you
might be exactly what people are looking
for in music!
Record labels are also looking for artists
that have a great personality and trend sense.
This is what they call the
"package."If you have a great voice,
or play an instrument really well, but on
top of that you are energetic, good looking,
and
very confident, it makes you more likely
to be signed than if you are negative and
arrogant.
Can an artist distribute their own music
without a record label?
Yes! A lot of artists have been doing that
these days. If you can fund the production
of your own albums, and have
enough cash to pay for a tour, you can book
your own tour dates in your local area, sell
your CDs at the venues, and
take home all the money! Plus the venue will
usually pay you a percentage of the door
charge.
Another way you can distribute your music
is through the Internet. If you have already
established a large enough
following, you can set up a website, and
sell your own albums through your website,
and that way you don't have to share
your money with anyone except yourself!